Tuesday, October 16, 2012

Week 3: Transfer and Metacognition

Hey guys so for this week I want you guys to distinguish the difference between Far and Near Transfer. Along with that, how is Metacognition relevant to Transfer? One last thing, I want you guys to name a specific example from LAST WEEK or THIS WEEK (whichever is the most current) that has to do with Transfer. It can be either Far or Near, or if you want, you are welcome to make both examples.

10 comments:

  1. Transfer is taking the application of skills, knowledge, and/or attitudes that were learned in one situation to another learning situation. Transfer of learning can be divided into two categories, near and far transfer. Near transfer is the overlap between situations, original and transfer contexts are similar. You can apply something you learned to a similar situation. Near transfer suggests that some problems and tasks are so nearly alike that transfer of learning occurs easily and naturally. When a nearly similar problem/task is encountered, it is solved with little or no conscious thought. However, far transfer is the little overlap between situations, original and transfer settings are dissimilar.

    Metacognition is relevant to transfer because “it can be improved by helping students become more aware of themselves as learners who actively monitor their learning strategies and resources and assess their readiness for particular tests and performances” (Bransford, 67). The definition of metacognition can be described as literally “thinking about thinking.” An example that I can think of that relates to metacognition and transfer is actually the activity that professor Kendall made us do which was trying to memorize the information in the passage and to then do another task, which was to solve the following problem. I felt like this was a great example on far transfer because the passage about the fortress, literally had nothing to do with the problem about the tumor. I had to be aware, monitor, and control my thinking on how to solve the problem of two totally different situations, in which I was able to solve because I transferred the information I did know, to help me solve the tumor problem. The method of transfer was used due to the connection of both the contexts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really liked the way you defined near transfer as an overlap of context. The word choice you used in your post helped me understand near and far transfer better. Also, thinking about metacognition and then the experiment we did in the class with the fortress and the tumor helped me understand my personal thinking process during class! Good job!

      Delete
  2. I think that Lyann did a great job coming up with an in-class example of metacognition and transfer. I was considering the same in class example using the Glen and Holyoak experiment where two seemingly unrelated tasks were actually useful in solving the other.

    I also think Lyann did a great job incorporating the definitions into the text to explain the difference between near and far transfer based on the contexts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This was supposed to be in response to Lyann's post...

      Delete
  3. The worksheet that we did in class this week really helped me identify the difference between near and far transfer. I originally thought that far transfer applied to drastically different situations, such as the class example using the general raiding a fortress to help solve a problem about a doctor using radiation on a tumor. The in class activity helped me distinguish that far transfer occurs when contexts are different. The example that stuck out to me was when a hypothetical person was taught how to use a cash-register in Macy's, and then it was easy for her to adapt to using a cash-machine at her next job in a restaurant. I would have thought of this as near transfer since they are both using a cash machine, which I considered similar. However, people brought up the different contexts (in a department store vs. in a restaurant) which means that it could also be considered far transfer.

    I agree with what Lyann said about the relevance of metacognition with regard to transfer. When students think about how they think (weird), they can better realize how the information that they're learning may apply to different situations.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I believe that the worksheet on transfer was helpful as well! It really helped us even see what vertical transfer was, since we all questioned it at first. Just like what Kendall said, the worksheet challenged me on what near transfer was.. Even though it still depends on how context is being defined.

      Delete
  4. As said in the Bransford reading, “It is especially important to understand the kinds of learning experiences that lead to transfer, defined as the ability to extend what has been learned in one context to new contexts.” As Bransford has defined transfer as the ability to extend what has been learned, the difference between far and near transfer is the “length” of the extension between one context to the next. Near transfer is when one is transferring what has been learned to a very similar context (as when it was originally learned.) Far transfer is when one is transferring what has been learned to a different context, but they are able to use accommodation and assimilation to fit what they have originally learned to the new context. Metacognition is defined as “thinking about thinking.” This concept is relevant to transfer because we can use metacognition when assessing our personal transfer of learning. During far transfer, sometimes we are unconsciously transferring prior knowledge learned into a new context. With metacognition, we can assess how our thinking process has developed in order for the far transfer to have occurred.

    An example of near transfer we have learned about this week was part of the worksheet in class when we discussed how if someone learned how to use a coffee machine at their own house, they are able to use a similar one at someone else’s house because they are able to take the original concept learned and apply it to a similar context. An example of far transfer from class would be when we memorized a passage that discussed the strategies an army used to invade a village discreetly and then applied this concept to removing a tumor using lasers. The strategies and concepts to both situations were similar, but the context was extremely different which made it a far transfer.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I like how you defined far and near transfer by stating that its the "length" of the extension between one context to the next. Usually, people define it by the similarity/dissimilarity of it, but how you described with "length" visually shows the learner on how the two definitions are different.

      Delete
  5. I like how you defined transfer and then specifically went into near and far transfer. I agree that metacognition helps individuals become more away of themselves and being about to reflect on one's personal thoughts is a very critical way of thinking and important when developing as a learner. A good point you brought up was how metacognition will help students successfully solve problems in the future as well.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Vivian did a great job incorporating the definitions of these concepts into her explanation, which really helped with regard to understanding how the concepts are all related. She also did a great job explaining "metacognition" since it's something I'm still confused about (how do you think about your thinking?)

    ReplyDelete