So for this week, I'm curious to know of what your guys' take on this... What is the role of the teacher and student when knowledge is being constructed? Think about Melissa and her teacher when answering this question (I believe this was on Cobb's reading)... and can you think of your experience where this similarly happened to you? Feel free to write freely and reflect on your daily experience as much as you would like. Shoot me any questions if you need any clarifications.
I believe that the role of the teacher and student changes based on a variety of factors including the students intellectual level, the goal of the lesson, the topic being studied, etc. However, in general, I believe that the teacher should serve as a guide and the student should act as an active learner.
ReplyDeleteWhen knowledge is being constructed, I believe that the student must be actively learning by engaging and considering knowledge he or she already has, and how she can build on that knowledge. For example, with Melissa in the reading, she was already able to do addition and subtraction using sums equal to or lower than fifteen. In the reading, her teacher aims to help Melissa construct knowledge in how to compute sums and differences for numbers greater than fifteen. The teacher served as a guide by providing Melissa alternative strategies and different ways of thinking about the problems that she was considering.
In my personal experience, I only remember constructing knowledge when I was learning my 9's multiplication tables. I learned if you take the number that you're multiplying by, subtract one, and find the difference between that number and nine, you have your product. I know that makes no sense, and I can explain it in person in groups if you guys want me to. ANYWAYS, my fourth grade teacher taught me this method and taught me how I could use my basic addition and subtraction to find my products for my nine's tables.
I agree that the role of a teacher and student changes based on many factors! You did a good job pointing out these factors and defining the role of a student in knowledge construction. It's great that you focused on the role of the student in knowledge construction because in class we discussed a lot about the teacher's role and not the student's role. Without active learning on the student's role, the teacher was trying to impose or negotiate would not make a difference.
DeleteWith the idea of constructivism in a classroom, I believe that the teacher should function more as a facilitator, someone who coaches, mediates, and prompts the student. The role of the teacher should be to help students develop and assess their understanding and their learning. The teacher shouldn’t be in the place to just pour knowledge into passive students who are like empty vessels to be filled, but to be guiders for the students in their learning and to help the learner get to his or her own understanding of the content. As for the students, their role is to be active learners. For example, as the teacher challenges the student by asking good questions to stimulate their way of thinking and understanding, the student can learn to become independent thinkers. Students can learn to “think outside the box” in a way where they can learn to discover principles, concepts and facts for themselves.
ReplyDeleteIn the story of Melissa, she was “an active constructor of knowledge who strove to overcome problems that arose as she interacted with the teacher” (95). The teacher played the role as a negotiator instead of teaching by imposition. Instead of constraining Melissa’s way of solving a problem, the teacher challenged her in a way where she modified the prior strategy she had to be able to solve problems that dealt with bigger numbers.
One example I can think of was when I was in my AP physics class back in high school. The teacher placed us all in groups and we were to discuss a homework problem. Even though the teacher knew the answer to the problem.. Instead of simply telling us the answer, she focused on helping us restate our questions in useful ways. She made us reflect on and examine our own current knowledge. She put herself in a place where she was basically walking with us through the process, where she used our prior knowledge to help us build off of that. When one of the students would come up with a concept where they thought was the answer, the teacher challenged the class show how they got to that conclusion. We designed and preformed experiments, which helped me a lot because I wasn’t just simply seeing the concepts with equations on paper, but I had to think and apply on my own. The teacher would have us all discuss our observations and experiments, which helped us have a better understanding of the concept.
First of all, kudos for actually using a quote in your analysis. I was going to do that, but got too lazy to walk across the room and look through my book to find an appropriate quote.
DeleteAnyways. I think Lyann and Vivian had many of the same points in emphasizing that teachers should act as guides and encourage students to learn the content in their own way, instead of simply giving the students the information that they need. In addition, both Lyann and Vivian point out that the students need to be active and engaged in their learning instead of passive. I liked Lyann's "empty vessel" analogy, similar to the one we used in lecture on Wednesday when we were first learning about learning (haha).
I liked how Lyann gives examples of how the teacher could be a mediator or coach, it gives a good perspective on the role of a teacher not being an information giver, but someone that helps construct knowledge in a student's mind! I have had similar experiences in classes where the teacher has you work in groups for solving problems and have found myself learning a lot when I am being an active learner in group problem solving situations. There also have been times where in a group I have been a passive learner, just sitting there and not participating in group discussions, and I definitely have not learned as much that way. I think that really connects with what Lyann was writing about when she defined the role of a student!
DeleteWhen first reading through the prompt I thought of the discussion we had on Friday about how the role of the teacher has changed as we've gotten older. When we were younger, we learned through many different types of forms. For example, I learned how to add by writing numbers, with blocks, toys, and story problems. These were all different representations of addition. As I've gotten older, the styles in which I've learn in school have changed. In my math classes in college, the teacher purely lectures and describes processes and information we should know and student take notes and are expected to retain. Drawing this back into the role of the teacher when knowledge is being constructed is understanding the topic and where the student is in their learning ability. When we were younger, we did not have a strong foundation for many subjects, it was the teacher’s job to build this foundation. To make us stronger learners, teachers should act as negotiators, shaping students to ask questions and experiment. The role of the teacher is very important in constructing knowledge because if they don’t understand the level of learning their students are at, the teacher may come across a “fish is fish” situation where the student is trying to understand, but they only know so much, so what they are receiving from the teacher is a bit skewed.
ReplyDeleteMelissa’s teacher helped construct her knowledge by trying to develop a way of learning that would fit Melissa instead of imposing a way of doing things. The role of a teacher as a negotiator is important because different students learn different ways. Teachers help guide students and stimulant their thinking processes. A student’s role is to actively learn by questioning and experimenting. An experience I've had similar to Melissa’s would be in my honors English class in high school where we would read different types of literature and then sit in a large circle in my class and have Socratic seminar. This was a special type of discussion because the teacher began with a prompt and then they would no longer involve themselves in the conversation. Students were not to raise their hands but all 30 of us were to have a group discussion about the prompt. This was very challenging and awkward at first, but it allowed us to develop our own ideas and really argue for our own ideas and try to figure out what is right and wrong and try to figure out what the teacher wanted us to get from the readings. It was very different compared to sitting in a class and being told what we were supposed to learn from our readings. I remember feeling nervous about these discussions, but I would always walk out of class feeling like I learned a lot about my readings, how other people interpreted the readings, and the ideas I personally developed from that class. These lessons would have not been possible from just sitting in a lectured based class.
I remember doing socratic seminars in high school too (so long ago..)! I really agree with what you said about how that activity was a good demonstration of constructivism in your experience. When I look back at my english class, through hearing out from others (since we all had to participate in it), we were able to build on top of each other's ideas, beliefs, disagreements, arguments.. And challenged each other in such a way where we all learned something new, compared to traditionally being in a class where only teacher lists their ideas.
DeleteSo far what was said a lot about the role of the teacher is to be the facilitator, the negotiator, etc.. but in this situation where the teacher was to step back and "be invisible" and let the students take the floor in discussion also helps students become active and self-direct learners as well, I think.
One of the things that stuck out to me in Vivian's explanation was that she described the student as being a self-directed learner. All of us have mentioned active learning, but I think Vivian brings up a great point in saying that the student is somewhat responsible for having interest in the material. The student needs to be directed in the sense that he or she takes initiative and is interested and engaged in what he or she is learning.
ReplyDeleteOne thing that I could really relate to with regard to Vivian's post was the personal example that she mentioned about her AP Chemistry class. It was very similar to a math class that I took my sophomore year of high school. In my math class, each group would be assigned a problem and we would have to go complete it on the board. Then the whole class would work together to follow the steps and make sure that the group had done the problem correctly. It again emphasizes the point that in order to construct knowledge, the students must be engaged and involved in their learning.
I felt like I could also relate to Vivian's example of her experience with constructivism. Just like my physics class, we both were able to actively learn in a way where it wasn't just memorizing a bunch of equations off the board from the teacher or anything.. But we were able to really go through the experimentation, class discussion, group interactions, and more to really understand the concepts from our classes. We were able to build from our prior knowledge to modify and introduce new ways of understanding more challenging concepts.
ReplyDelete