Sunday, September 30, 2012
Week 1: Behaviorism... Mastery vs. Understanding
Many schools today are so focused in getting high scoring tests so that they would get more funds. Many of these high scoring tests are achieved through more of "mastery" than "understanding". Technically, the schools have accomplished their goals by getting all of these high scores. But the flaws lie on the fact that many students are not understanding the materials thoroughly, but able to use memorization to achieve the correct answers. So I am curious to know, if you were a principal of a school, how much "mastery" or "understanding" would you lay your school's foundations on? What are the benefits and flaws of both mastery and understanding? Is getting the right scores (which eventually leads to more funding) more important than the concept of "understanding"? If so, why? If not, why? Feel free to write as much as you can. Just think about it as journal writing.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
If I was the principal of a school, I would place emphasis on both mastery and understanding. I think that it is important for students to both understand and master concepts in order to properly learn a subject. If I were to put the concepts in relative terms, I would emphasize 75% understanding and 25% mastery. I believe that this ratio would provide students with a solid foundation to understand the materials that they are learning, and the 25% mastery would provide students with the skills necessary to provide correct answers on standardized tests and evaluations.
ReplyDeleteBenefits of understanding include improved comprehension of the subject that students are being taught, as well as a solid foundation of skills so that students can better understand material when the skills become more complex. Students who understand better will also be better able to apply the skills that they have learned, as well as help teach peers who are struggling with the material. One downfall of understanding is that not all students will thoroughly learn and understand material at the same rate; some students will be struggling to keep up with the class pace, while other students are bored with the material.
I consider mastery to regard to the mastering of concepts, in the sense that students are able to adequately understand and repeat the sequence of steps to solve certain types of problems. This is beneficial because students who master concepts will be confident in their ability to perform on certain tasks and assignments. These students will also excel in standardized tests. The downfall of mastery is that students may sometimes master the order of steps without understanding the logic behind each step. I can relate to this in my experience taking Math 125 (Calculus II) at UW. I was able to get correct answers by following the sequence, but had no idea WHY I was completing these steps.
I think that the concept of understanding is more important than the concept of mastery because it will provide students with a solid foundation upon which they can improve their education in a variety of subject areas.
I thought it was interesting when you pointed out that for mastery, students can be more confident in their ability to perform on certain tasks and assignments. I noted that too but I listed it under the benefits for understanding. Reflecting on both of these posts, it makes me realize that both concepts can be used as a way to build up the student's confidence and motivation for learning which can also further put a positive influence on the student's way of thinking and scores on a test, but of course it depends on the student.
DeleteI thought a great point Kendall brought up was that a downfall to understanding is that not all students will learn at the same rate. This is definitely a challenge not only for students personally, but to their peers because teachers need to take into consideration the pace their class as a whole is learning at. Because of that, curriculum could be too fast paced for some students or too slow for others. What would be a good way to balance this out?
DeleteAnother great point that I never thought of was the emotional development of students correlating to mastery and understanding. The concept of confidence is a great benefit of mastery and it is important to help students not only master concepts when learning but help students develop their confidence in learning as well!
After learning the concepts of mastery and understanding, I do believe that both concepts are very significant when it comes to educational learning. It is important for the student to work for correct answers, but at the same time, grasp the concept of understanding of what led them to get the right answer. But if I was a principal of a school and I had to specifically determine how much of the two concepts should be stressed in an educational setting, I believe that 30% mastery and 70% understanding should be the appropriate amount.
ReplyDeleteThere are many benefits and flaws of both mastery and understanding. Mastery serves as an obvious and helpful tool which gives concrete ways of determining which students have successfully mastered certain concepts and skills. To whoever it may concern, mastery is helpful in which improvement can be easily illustrated. For example, a student is making progress in their learning of the subject. However, mastery may not be truly beneficial for the student, depending on the process of how they got to the right answer. Students can simply memorize their way without really understanding just for the goal to pass a class. Mastery does a poor job of articulating what we really want our students to learn as a result of their time in the classes.
Understanding increases comprehension of the subject and encourages students to take what they learn for application. Students can be more confident in themselves and with understanding of the subject. They are more likely to become more motivated to learn and are able to teach on what they have learned to others who don’t have fully understand. There are also some flaws of understanding, one of which it may weed out some students from getting a good score on a test, which can hurt the percentage of how well the students are doing on tests. Not everyone has the same pace on understanding material at the same pace, in which can disrupt the pace of the class.
Both concepts are important but really understanding the material and concept serves as a greater goal than simply mastering the concept. Getting funding for the school is significant and I do realize that the more the students can master the material (shown from their test scores), it will increase funding. On the other hand, we have to take consideration of what we really want out of the students in education. If the educational goal behind it all is to see improvement in the student’s learning, preparing them for the future, and teaching them lifelong values, discipline, and the ability to explore new ideas and think independently, understanding rather than mastery would be most beneficial for the students.
I think that Lyann does a great job summarizing her argument in the last paragraph. It is true that funding for schools is scarce, and educators should do everything in their power to raise test scores to increase funding. But she also brings up how important it is to realize that simply teaching students to get correct answers won't provide the quality education that all children have a right to.
DeleteLyann's reflection of how our emphasis on mastery versus understanding reflect what we really want our students to learn as a result of their time in classrooms. I never really thought about how students' understanding and mastery in school reflects how adults are helping shape the future world. It makes me wonder if future jobs will cater towards students who can accomplish mastery and how much consideration will employers take in their employees' understanding of concepts. If employees can master a task and get the job done correctly, will it matter to employers if their employees understand their jobs?
DeleteMy favorite part of Lyann's post was when she said "If the educational goal behind it all is to see improvement in the student’s learning, preparing them for the future, and teaching them lifelong values, discipline, and the ability to explore new ideas and think independently, understanding rather than mastery would be most beneficial for the students." I agree that schools should not only be emphasizing learning subjects as math and science, but instilling values, discipline, and the ideas of exploration in students as well... all to build a better future!
In my ideal world, mastery and understanding would go hand in hand; one would not exist without the other. In class so far, we have defined mastery and understanding as two different things. Mastery as the process of being able to complete a task or question efficiently whereas understanding is the process of knowing and comprehending a subject.
ReplyDeleteBefore this class, I would have defined mastery as the ability to UNDERSTAND something AND produce an efficient product of one’s learning (i.e. the correct answers). If I were the principal of a school, I would try to lay my school’s foundation on a combination of understanding and mastery. A student should understand something while mastering it at the same time. It is a teacher’s job to help students understand lessons and processes taught in school and it is a student’s job to master what is taught in school. As a principal I would emphasize using class time to understand, learn, and ask questions, while time outside of school (homework time, extracurricular time, and “at home” time) should be spent mastering subjects taught.
The benefit of understanding is having full comprehension of what is taught. I believe that if one understands something, they should be able to teach it to others and have the flexibility to apply the subject outside the classroom. For example, students should be able to apply their understanding of math to the outside world by being able to do things such as adding prices up at a grocery store before checking out instead of just being able to add 2 + 2 on a whiteboard.
The benefit of mastering a subject is being able to produce correct answers! There are flaws in mastery because mastery can be completed through memorization and imitation, which means there is no deeper understanding of a topic. From the example before, if a student has only mastered math on a whiteboard, then they may not make the connection of adding prices in a grocery store or understand that math can be used outside of the classroom or the student could not explain the reasoning behind how they got an answer.
Getting the right answers are important; however it can never replace the concept of understanding. As Skinner emphasizes the use of reinforcement and mechanical aids in the process of mastery, there is no way to replace a teacher with a mechanical aid. A teacher is there for students to ask questions and deepen their knowledge upon subjects which eventually leads to their understanding (and hopefully mastery!) of topics. Schools should use funding as an incentive for students to excel in school, but in order for mastery and understanding to come in full circle, a school needs to decide on what their definition of excelling is. Is it for students to master a subject? Is it for students to understand subjects? Or is excelling a combination of both?
Funding and quality education should not be compromised for the mastery of test taking and assessment. For the purpose of schools is for students to learn and understand, not for students to replicate and memorize.
I think that one of the things that Aimy did a really great job bringing into perspective is how big of a difference it can when we describe "mastery" in different ways.
DeleteErlwanger focuses on "mastery" as the ability to recreate answers and determine correct responses to do well on a test or assignment. When we consider mastery to be a matter of truly mastering or understanding a concept, it becomes significantly more relevant in the world of education.
I agree with the statement in the last paragraph, that "getting the right answers are important; however it can never replace the concept of understanding." I think this does a great job summarizing all of our perceptions on the significance of both mastery and understanding.
Aimy made a great point on describing how mastery and understanding cannot simply be used without the help of another. Both of the concepts are integrated and provide benefits for education. When she wrote "it is a teacher's job to help students understand lessons and processes taught in school and it is a student's job to master what is taught in school," made me realize the ideal picture of how mastery and understanding come into play to promote the most effectiveness for education. The teachers help students understand and the students should be able to master the subject of what they understand. This illustrates how both concepts are highly dependable on each other and results to better outcomes, rather than simply using one concept instead.
DeleteI agree that understanding does create a strong foundation n which to build students' future knowledge,comprehension, and mastery upon, it is indeed a very important aspect of learning through the entire education.
ReplyDeleteI also noticed similar things to Vivian while growing up. There was a lot of emphasis on different styles of learning and making sure the foundation of understanding was laid out when growing up, but as we got older, there was a larger emphasis on producing the correct answers, which could be the result of standardized testing becoming more significant in the education system.