Tuesday, October 30, 2012
Week 5: Development
So for this week, since the topic is "Development", I'm curious to know, what do you guys think the difference between learning and developing? How are they similar? How are they different? Does culture affect development differently than it affects learning? How does culture play a role in this matter? Also, you could think about this week's blog as an extensive blog or an addition to last week's blog (last week's was about sociocultural theory and this week is about cultural development). Just to keep in mind, there's no right or wrong answer, I would just like to know what you guys think about this.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Truth be told, I'm still having a really hard time determining the difference between learning and development. When we initially started discussing this concept, I still considered "development" to refer to the physical process of growth and change. I also considered learning to be a part of development, and thought that development was required for learning. I thought of the example of my 9 month old cousin learning to walk; he can't learn to walk until his muscles develop the strength and tone to support his body.
ReplyDeleteNow that I realize that development is a much broader term than that, I'm having a hard time figuring out how learning and development relate and connect. I believe that they are very closely interrelated and you can't have one without the other. I also think that learning refers more to mental processes and the knowledge and skills that are acquired, whereas development refers to how we acquire the knowledge and how we perceive the knowledge based on our experiences.
When we first started learning about development I also considered "development" the physical process of growth and change. I also thought a lot about previous biology classes I have taken and the lessons we've learned about "brain development." The development of how we learn, however, is a much bigger concept than our brains just growing.
DeleteAfter discussing learning and development with our group, I definitely agree the two concepts are very closely interrelated and you can't have one without the other, but it is still a difficult concept to me how they are tied together. If learning refers to more of a mental process does that mean mental tools are being used? And don't mental tools stem from socio-culture which is very close to development which is culture based? (Do they ties even make sense?)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe that learning does have a play with mental tools. Learning is acquiring knowledge and internalizing it. It's taking it in one's mind. I believe that internalization connects well with mental tools because it's about HOW we can internalize it as well. Not everyone will use the same mental tools to help them remember or understand things. Mental tools does relate to socio-culture and I believe it all ties back with development too.
DeleteOne of the things that Vivian brought up in her blog post was the same thing that Kendall brought up in class on Monday, that learning can potentially happen in an instant whereas development happens over a course of time. I also like how she differentiated that learning is the process of taking in information, whereas development is how you take it in. I think that Vivian and I have very similar ideas in that learning and development are very closely connected, and you can't have one without the other. Vivian did a great job including what an important role culture has in both learning and development.
ReplyDeleteIt has take me quite some time to wrap my head around the difference between learning and development, but this is my stab at it for now.
ReplyDeleteTo me, learning is acquiring information. In learning, there is an external source and the student takes information from that external source. Developing, however, is the process of taking information. In other words, development comes from how one learns, not what one learns. Development stems from the culture one grows in. Characteristics of culture such as the environment one is growing up in, the social norms, and other norms all affect the way in which a person develops and grows.
During this week we compared Piaget and Rogoff’s different definitions of development and discussed the difference. Rogoff’s definition of development incorporated how humans develop within their culture and how learning is very dependent on cultural characteristics one grows up in. This is a little different compared to Piaget who defined development very structurally, assuming most children develop the same way around the same age and to be developmentally successful you had to hit certain stages at certain times in your life. Thinking about how these two definitions of development are different make me realize that maybe they have a relationship with each other. Another group in class did a representation that showed learning and development working together, which really clicked with me. It made me wonder is it possible to develop without learning or is it possible to learn without development? I think they depend on each other for an individual to be successful. Being developed helps one learn and learning is part of developing.
I agree with Aimy in how she differentiates learning and development. I also think that learning is a matter of the student taking in information, whereas development refers to how the student takes in that information. In the second paragraph, she does a really good job differentiating between Rogoff and Piaget's definitions of development.
DeleteI agree that I don't think learning and development could occur without the other. One great point you made was that culture affects BOTH learning and development and not JUST development which is what our readings focused on. Using the word "framework" to describe how culture effects our development is great and it reminds me of our representation for Rogoff's definition of development where the clay boy is sitting in the "middle of his culture" while it was framing him!
ReplyDelete"learning could also happen in a moment, while development happens over a period of time." really helps me understand the difference between these two concepts and makes me think about how they have a relationship even though they are different. Why do we associate these two words together?
At first when we were given the assignment to define the differences between learning and development, I thought of learning as just acquiring knowledge and development was like physical development.. But through after attending the Friday's mentorship, I believe I got a better understanding of the two differences. Through the mentorship, we decided that a clear way (for us at least) to understand these two terms was that learning was "acquiring knowledge" and development was "HOW you acquire the knowledge." Learning is gaining new knowledge and internalizing it. It shows the understanding of the knowledge and the acquisition of fundamental behavior or practical info. Development is a form of learning that is culture based. It is understanding cultural norms and cultural practices, and defined as cultural processes. Culture significantly affects development differently than it affects learning because its the way we develop. We all internalize but we internalize differently. Our culture shapes how we develop. I believe that this blog is an addition to last week's blog because I see the connection with sociocultural theory with culture and how it's the framework of one's mind.
ReplyDeleteAssociating learning and development together really challenges both the teachers and the students on what real learning is. Because we need to take culture into consideration and how it its a huge part of how we learn and develop. It really challenged me to know the definitions and the differences between the terms.
ReplyDelete