Week 8: Motivation
Pretty much like what we just talked about... in regards to school, are you more intrinsically motivated or extrinsically motivated when it comes to school today? How about when you were in elementary, middle, and high school? How has your motivation evolved? Let me know if you have any questions.
When I began taking classes, I was primarily extrinsically motivated, particularly by my parents telling me that getting good grades would help me get to middle school, high school, college, etc. As I said in our discussion, intrinsic motivation probably kicked in in third grade. Like Aimy said, this was when I began standardized testing and realized that I was competent in all of the school subjects, and was placed into a "Special and Gifted Education Program." Since school was something I was good at, I enjoyed doing homework, reading, and being involved in school (nerd, I know).
ReplyDeleteIn middle school, it was probably a balance of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, and in high school as well. High school shifted more towards intrinsic motivation because I knew that these grades would go onto college applications and have significant implications for my future.
Freshman year of college, I hated school and wanted to transfer. I was only motivated extrinsically by my parents and peers who were all so educationally oriented. But I was taking Calculus, Chemistry, and Biology (pre-nursing) and wasn't doing well in any of my classes. Since I no longer felt competent, I didn't enjoy doing school work and didn't see the importance. This continued through sophomore year until I started taking psychology, sociology, and early childhood classes that interested me more. I then became more intrinsically motivated.
Now, I consider myself more intrinsically motivated, but also significantly extrinsically motivated too. I am intrinsically motivated in that I love the classes I'm taking and am genuinely interested in what I am learning, which makes me happy(ish) to complete the readings and assignments. However, I'm also extrinsically motivated because of my aspirations to go to graduate school, which I know will help me in my career path based on what I know about the field.
My motivation develop was very similar to yours, starting out extrinsically and then developing to a balance between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation and finally developing to being intrinsically motivated. It is interesting to think about how extrinsic and intrinsic motivations balance each other out, I wonder if they can really work together or they shift between each other? I definitely feel the pain you felt during science classes when I was pre-nursing/pre-med I was miserable in all my classes. As soon as I switched into ECFS I finally felt like I was getting something out of my college education.
DeleteNow that you consider yourself more intrinsically motivated how do you think your extrinsic motives effect your intrinsic motives? Do you think being aware of motivations affect your way of thinking about your interests?
KENDALL, I TOTALLY RELATE TO YOU. I understand what you mean by only being extrinisically motivated in school during freshman year. I also took a bunch of pre-med classes where I felt like I wasn't competent or academic enough in my classes by the grades I recieved from basically weed out classes. The only reason why I stayed was because of the influence by peers, because my friends were in my classes as well. We all had a plan that we would be on the premed route together or how my parents would push and encourage me to highly (only is a better word) for medical school.
DeleteI believe that in college/university, intrinsic motivation should be more emphasized. Students should be doing what they love to do, something that they just have that natural wanting to challenge themselves.. because I believe that if one has a natural interest/motivation for it, they will far succeed better than just by the pressure of others.
I agree with Lyann in that college should bring about a change of primarily extrinsic motivation, and I think that's something that comes with the territory. College is the first time that people get to choose their classes and schedules, which is a change and means that people are generally learning about things that will motivate them intrinsically.
DeleteWhen you say that you think that a natural interest/motivation for it will be more successful than pressure from others... How do you think extrinsic motivation is affected when you are more naturally interested in a certain subject?
I remember when I started Kindergarten I didn't really understand what school was, my mom taught me how to read and write before I started Kindergarten so I felt as if the teacher wasn't "teaching" me much, but giving me task to do in class. My motivation then was very extrinsic, I was completing task for my teachers and my parents told emphasized the importance of school and education, but I didn't really understand what "learning" was until I got older.
ReplyDeleteLike we discussed yesterday, I started noticing motivations and school became more important when I was introduced to standardized testing. Still at that time, I was very extrinsicly motivated in school, I tried my best because I enjoyed completing task and succeeding, but I was not really motivated for my personal gain. It wasn't until high school when I began taking classes such as marketing, biology, and humanities that I understand that we could have a deeper personal connection to what we were learning and could enjoy school on a personal level. I tried to find motivation from high school up to college that would give me personal enjoyment. In high school I took a few science classes and thought I was interested in biology, this was "phase 1" of my interest development, but as I continued my studies at the beginning of college I began to dread my biology and chemistry courses and quickly lost interest. It wasn't until I started working kids and studied education that I really felt like I was getting the most out of my college studies. I was finally motivated to do my school work and found what I studied interesting and could see it being applicable to life outside of school. My motivations have evolved since then because my interests have developed and I have personal attachment to what I am interested in and motivated to make it part of my life (my motives evolved from extrinsic to instrinsic).
As we talked about in class today, the phases of interests development are important. Looking back through my high school and college experiences of personal exploration I have grown a lot as a person and learner by trying different things that have sparked my interest and have decided what motivates me and what doesn't. Seeing my phases of interest grow or diminish show what has motivated and captivated me throughout my learning experiences.
Aimy, you made a good point on standardized testing with motivation. I believe that tests plays a huge role on how motivated we as students are. I feel like it can either intrinsically or extrinsically motivate us because standardized testing can either push us to do better for ourselves or it can involve ego-involvement to do better than the other where we are pressured/influenced by others.
DeleteNow that I'm doing this blog post so late and we've started learning about assessment, it's really interesting for me to consider the role of assessment in motivation. Is assessment an extrinsic or intrinsic motivator? If a student is motivated by the desire to get a good grade for him or herself is that intrinsic motivation?
DeleteI find it interesting that all of us became more extrinsically motivated after the introduction of standardized testing.
It's really interesting to see how your pathway of motivation started out intrinsically whereas I consider my motivations extrinsic at first because when I was young I was such a "blank slate" to interests, not really knowing about much and just doing what others told me. To me, factors such as friends and songs are more extrinsic motives and wanting to learn how to read and write are intrinsic motives, what do you think?
ReplyDeleteWhat I noticed you, Kendall, and I all have in common in our posts is that we all went through classes in college that did not interest us, but in the end, we found our interests and have become more intrinsically motivated. You can see the phases of interest occur in all our posts as we try to find different subjects to motivate our education. I thought that it was interesting that in all three of our posts we each stated that we are more intrinsically motivated now. Initially I thought about how perhaps you have to be "mature" or go through difference experiences to be intrinsically motivated, but it is really interesting to hear about how you were at such a young age! I wonder how age and experiences affect motivation...
(I remember this question from our video conference!!)
ReplyDeleteBetween the two types of motivations, I felt like I have always been influenced more by extrinsic motivation. When it came to grade school, my parents have always pressured me to do well in school and have always reminded me why I should do well in school. I became motivated not just because I became interested myself, but because others have pushed, challenged, and encouraged me too. Even to this day, I find myself being influenced and interested more when I am given praise and encouragement. But there are other examples of me being more intrinsically motivated, such as devoting my time to doing something I love to do and to get better at it. Examples such as, playing basketball. No one has ever told me to play, but I just wanted to engage in the sport to exercise my capacities and to seek out and master optimal challenges of playing basketball. I want to play basketball, not for anyone else but for myself.