- Take pictures of things or circumstances in your everyday life that position people as able and/or disabled
- Post at least 1 picture (so feel free to do more than 1) on your blog, and talk about how assumptions about intelligence, ability and disability are a part of your everyday life.
And also if you want... I have these questions that I think would be good for you guys to keep in mind. I want to hear what you guys think about when people use the word "intelligence, competence, or ability". They might say, “Johnny is so smart!” or “My cousin has a disability” When they say Johnny is smart, do you think they mean intelligent? or competent? or able? Do these words kind of mean the same thing? Why or why not? From your guys' past experiences, do you think people use these words under the right circumstances? Can you give me an anecdote of what happened? Feel free to think of this as optional but I am so curious on what you guys have to say about this....
So this might be a stupid question... But how do I post the picture I took?
ReplyDeletehttp://imgur.com/uq5QC
ReplyDeleteThe picture I took (linked above) is a picture of a restroom sign outside the school I volunteer at. This sign says "RESTROOM" in English, there is a picture of a man and a woman, and there is also (I'm assuming because I can't read braille!) braille that symbolizes the bathroom. There are many assumptions that go along with this sign:
Assumption #1
People who need to use the bathroom can read English. Since the sign is in no other language, it is assumed that everyone reading this sign will be able to read English.
Assumption #2
People who cannot read the sign in English can read braille.
Assumption #3
People will be able to understand that because there is a man and a woman in the picture, they can assume it is a "unisex" bathroom.
Assumption #4
People will understand what the word "restroom" means (compared to the other terms for restroom such as bathroom or water closet).
I don't want to make the sign seem bad, it's a great sign, but there are many assumptions people have made while making this sign. It makes me wonder would you be considered disabled if you can't understand these types of signs that are directed for everyone in the public to understand?
With your comment saying that you didn't want to make the sign seem bad.. I was reading over your assumptions again and I thought to myself that I don't see anything with the sign "seeming bad" or thinking that it would promote any negativity. But then again, maybe because I can fit these assumptions where I do understand what the sign means and I can read English.. This week has been challenging me on the true definition of disability. I think to some extent if they don't understand the sign (like..if they can't see but will need to use the braille) will make them disabled.
DeleteBut what extent to which it can be painted black or white when there's a certainty that the person can be labeled as disabled? (I dont know if this makes sense, let me know).
One of the things that I see in this is how many cultural meanings are incorporated into the sign such as the English language, the braille, and the image. All of these things seem familiar to those who have grown up in the culture, however, many people from other cultures may have no idea what these signs or symbols mean.
DeleteI agree with Lyann that I didn't see anything particularly negative (or positive) about the sign. I think of it as being just a sign. Since you see it as a potentially bad sign, what would you do to improve the sign?
The picture that I took…literally if you walk by Savery Hall, you’ll find it when you’re walking to the Quad ☺ It’s the ramp and the staircase.
ReplyDeletehttp://tinypic.com/r/24nr3om/6
Assumption #1
People who cannot walk and would think that taking the stairs wouldn’t be convenient would use the ramp to walk to the Quad. Its assumed that not everyone will be able to use the stairs.
Assumption #2
There are more people that will use the stairs because the stairs seem to be larger than the ramp’s width.
Assumption #3
The ramp will be used for people in wheel chairs because they cannot use the stairs.
There are probably more assumptions but these are the only ones I can think of right now..
I thought about taking a picture of a wheel chair ramp too because I actually use to walk to Suzzallo library all the time because sometimes it is just less crowded to walk that way! Sometimes though I feel as if I am getting in the way of disabled people when I use ramps as pathways to walk because there is less traffic. It makes me wonder if it is bad to use these adjustments in the environment if we are not "disabled?" I thought it was great how you compared the size of the wheel chair ramps to the stairs... it makes me wonder how people who designed ramps and portioned them were thinking when they were considering the disabled population.
DeleteI think it's a very good observation that you made Vivian about how our society tries its best to make accommodations for disability. It's true, I can see the thought put it in when I see ramps, escalators, elevators, buttons for doors to open, etc.. But I do strongly agree that our society still considers being disabled is a minority. There is still segregation and judgement towards the disabled. And I asked this question on my post.. but seriously, what extent does it take for someone to be really labeled as disabled? When we can physically see that there's "something wrong with them," making it difficult for them to complete a task like most? Or can wearing glasses be labeled as a disability as well?
ReplyDeleteI thought about a crosswalk sign when thinking about this assignment too. I use a crosswalk every day when I walk to campus, and it's only visual (no audio signal). So I was wondering what happens when people who are blind try to cross this crosswalk? You did a great job identifying that this particular crosswalk sign accommodates for both the able and the disabled by providing visual and auditory signals.
ReplyDeleteI agree that people who are disabled are still considered a minority, however our society has come a long way to make accommodations and to be more accepting. It used to be that disabled people were all sent to institutions. People are now much more understanding about how to help people with disabilities, however, like Vivian said, there is still much work to be done to accommodate for ALL people with ALL disabilities in ALL situations.
http://tinypic.com/r/2419kbq/6
ReplyDeleteHere's a link to my picture. It's just a picture of a disabled parking sign outside of the yoga studio I take classes at.
One assumption with this sign is that the person who is driving, while disabled, is still capable of driving a car. Whatever disability they have doesn't limit their ability to drive. This sign also assumes that the driver/audience can speak or read English as the sign says "Reserved Parking: State Disabled Parking Permit Required." For those who can't read English, the sign assumes that there is a cultural meaning of the picture of an individual in a wheelchair on the background. This sign representing disability is often seen in elevators, bathrooms, parking, etc.
This assignment and your blog post has really made me thought about the language that is used in disabilities signed. Almost all the ones I've seen or have thought about have been in English (some of have braille or sounds, but the majority have been in English). What a big assumption it is that people with disabilities can understand signs in English. Do you think the assumption that a driver/audience that is disabled can speak or read English is impactful on society? If you were to change this sign, what would it look like?
Delete